Life is Feudal Official Forum

[Burne109]

Hello,

If i am not in a guild, and I set up a personal claim
(not on a guild claim) and judgement hour hits

Can players,
1. Destroy all my claims buildings
2. Loot everything
3. Destroy the claim monument
4. All the above


Thanks for the replies

[Sharana]

1) Cast a ritual to revoke your personal claim (like 10min maybe).
2) Do all the above as there is nothing protecting your stuff.

[Burne109]

so personal claims are worthless. bummer.

[Sharana]

so personal claims are worthless. bummer.

They are not. At the same time they can't be too protected all the time as that will be really abused.

[Balandar]

Do they have to stand on the claim to cast the ritual? Can you have a wall around your personal claim?

[Ragemaster9999]

1) Cast a ritual to revoke your personal claim (like 10min maybe).
2) Do all the above as there is nothing protecting your stuff.

I don't believe this is correct. Patch notes say you can only do it if on a guild claim. Hes talking about just having a personal claim out in the wilderness.

Also Instanced battles will replace JH mechanic. If you can just destroy any personal claim you walk by it will completely make them pointless.

[Sharana]

1) Cast a ritual to revoke your personal claim (like 10min maybe).
2) Do all the above as there is nothing protecting your stuff.

I don't believe this is correct. Patch notes say you can only do it if on a guild claim. Hes talking about just having a personal claim out in the wilderness.

Also Instanced battles will replace JH mechanic. If you can just destroy any personal claim you walk by it will completely make them pointless.

The same question as in Discord - wouldn't you abuse the sh*t out of them if they weren't vulnerable? I personally see countless ways to abuse them if the enemy can't get rid of them. Balance between guilds and solo players is impossible - the solo safe zone is either far away from everyone or near the central city where PvP is disabled.

Also not all the time - during the vulnerability window. If you are online during that like 19-22 time window you can defend against 1-3 players, but don't stand a chance vs a bigger group ofc. That's the thing that makes you settle up on guild claim for protection. The realm claims of tier 3 and 4 monument are really big - that's not without purpose.

[Paulchatterton]

There is no Judgement Hour. The battle system has replaced it. Battles can only take place between guilds with at least a tier 2 monument.

I don't believe personal claims are vulnerable to battle. The only thing personal claims are vulnerable to is being consumed by a guild claim.

[Burne109]

There is no Judgement Hour. The battle system has replaced it. Battles can only take place between guilds with at least a tier 2 monument.

I don't believe personal claims are vulnerable to battle. The only thing personal claims are vulnerable to is being consumed by a guild claim.

Id be pretty sad if some guild placed a claim near my personal claim just to grief it. Poof take it over cast the deletion spell and boom goes the buildings and the stuff i made.

There should be a Claim build radious limit to keep people from building guild claims too close to Personal claims.. to keep that from happening.

[Paulchatterton]

Id be pretty sad if some guild placed a claim near my personal claim just to grief it. Poof take it over cast the deletion spell and boom goes the buildings and the stuff i made.

There should be a Claim build radious limit to keep people from building guild claims too close to Personal claims.. to keep that from happening.

As a guild only has one claim, the guild would have to be very sad indeed to build their claim just to grief you. It's possible that they could create 10 alts for a new guild but they would need a ticket to the mainland for each, and they'd need materials to build it. I'd say your only real danger is if you build your personal claim in a prime spot that everyone wants, in which case it doesn't seem so unreasonable that you would get pushed out. Of course, you always have the option of joining the guild, in which case the guild leader can allow you to keep your personal claim.

[DemonianAzeroth]

There is no Judgement Hour. The battle system has replaced it. Battles can only take place between guilds with at least a tier 2 monument.

I don't believe personal claims are vulnerable to battle. The only thing personal claims are vulnerable to is being consumed by a guild claim.

Id be pretty sad if some guild placed a claim near my personal claim just to grief it. Poof take it over cast the deletion spell and boom goes the buildings and the stuff i made.

There should be a Claim build radious limit to keep people from building guild claims too close to Personal claims.. to keep that from happening.

This is the nature of Life being Fuedal